Percentage (flat) method
22% federal flat rate. What most employers use.
| Bonus | $10000.00 |
| Federal supplemental (22%) | −$2200.00 |
| FICA (SS + Medicare) | −$765.00 |
| State (est.) | −$660.00 |
| Effective withholding rate | 36.3% |
Aggregate method
Bonus added to a regular check, then taxed.
| Bonus | $10000.00 |
| Federal withholding (on bonus) | −$2811.70 |
| FICA (SS + Medicare) | −$765.00 |
| State (est.) | −$660.00 |
| Effective withholding rate | 42.4% |
Average vs. marginal federal rate (aggregate scenario)
The average rate is the share of the whole bonus withheld for federal income tax. The marginal rate is the bracket the last dollar of the combined check lands in. Marginal is usually higher than average, which is why the aggregate method can withhold more than a flat 22%.
What counts as supplemental wages
Bonuses, commissions, severance, back pay, retroactive pay raises, awards and prizes, accumulated sick leave paid out, and overtime in some cases. Anything paid in addition to regular wages.
The percentage method
22 percent flat federal withholding on supplemental wages up to $1 million per year. 37 percent on amounts above $1 million. Easy to calculate. Predictable. Most employers use it.
The aggregate method
Add the supplemental wage to the regular paycheck. Calculate withholding on the combined amount as if it were a single regular paycheck. Subtract what would have been withheld on the regular wages alone. The remainder is the supplemental withholding.
Result is usually higher than the percentage method because the larger combined check pushes annualized income into a higher bracket.
State supplemental rates
Most states have their own supplemental withholding rate. They vary widely. Some use a flat percentage, some use the aggregate method, some treat supplemental wages identically to regular wages. Verify with your state.
FICA still applies
Bonuses are subject to Social Security (6.2 percent up to the wage base) and Medicare (1.45 percent on every dollar). Plus the 0.9 percent Additional Medicare on wages above $200,000.
Withholding versus tax owed
The 22 percent is withholding, not your actual tax rate. If your effective rate is below 22 percent, the over-withholding refunds at filing time. If above, you may owe more on your return.
Ways to reduce bonus withholding
- Direct part of the bonus into 401(k) or HSA via payroll, reducing taxable wages.
- Set Step 4(b) deductions on the W-4 if you itemize.
- Adjust Step 4(c) extra withholding negative is not allowed, but you can submit a new W-4 to lower future regular-wage withholding to compensate.
The myth in one sentence
Bonuses are not taxed at a higher rate. They are withheld at a flat rate that often over-collects, and the over-collection comes back at filing.